Today, I am posting a wonderful performance of the Rachmaninoff Third Piano Concerto in D Minor by Emil Gilels and André Cluytens. I have posted Gilels before, and he is one of the great pianists of the 20th century. I have not posted André Cluytens before. Cluytens was a Flemish conductor who moved to France and had expertise in the French orchestral repertory. He was also a wonderful conductor of a broad spectrum of classical styles. In addition to the Rachmaninoff, I have also posted Cluytens conducting Ravel’s La Valse and the prelude to Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg. These are both extraordinary performances, and they are worth the time to listen to.
André Cluytens
March 26, 1905 – June 3, 1967
At the time of his son’s birth, André Cluytens’s father was conductor at the Theatre Royal in Antwerp. The boy thus grew up surrounded by music and entered the Royal Flemish Conservatory aged only nine. Here he distinguished himself as a pianist, winning first prizes for piano, harmony, and counterpoint. Immediately after graduating in 1922, he joined the staff of the Theatre Royal, working with his father as a répétiteur and chorusmaster. In 1927, he succeeded his father as the conductor of the theater and made his professional conducting debut with Bizet’s Les Pecheurs de Perles. He enjoyed considerable success in Antwerp, for instance when he directed the local premiere of Richard Strauss’s Salome.
With his appointment as chief conductor of the Toulouse Opera in 1932, Cluytens moved to France, establishing himself as part of the country’s considerable regional operatic life, as well as taking French nationality. From 1935, he conducted at Lyons and Bordeaux, and during World War II moved to Paris, where he worked in the Paris Opera. He also started to record, for instance in 1943 conducting the Paris Conservatory Orchestra in Marcelle Mayer’s recording of Richard Strauss’s Burleske, and after the war, in 1946, he signed a recording contract with the French branch of EMI Pathé-Marconi. Cluytens’s career took a major step forward in 1947 with his appointment as chief conductor of the Opéra-Comique in Paris. Here he was to conduct forty different works between 1947 and 1953 with Carmen, Louise, and La Bohème among the most frequently heard. As head of the historic company, with an unrivalled tradition in the performance of many of the masterpieces of the French repertoire, Cluytens was the natural choice to conduct several of its recordings for EMI. These included legendary account of Offenbach’s Les Contes d’Hoffmann, Bizet’s Carmen, and Ravel’s L’Heure Espagnole.
In 1949, by now establishing himself as one of the leading conductors in France, Cluytens took over from Charles Munch as the chief conductor of the concerts of the Paris Conservatory Orchestra. At the same time the advent of the long-playing record and its gradual adoption throughout Europe triggered a demand for new recordings: Cluytens was to play a significant part in the activity which followed. In 1952, he was engaged by EMI in England to accompany Solomon in his recordings of Beethoven’s Piano Concertos Nos. 2 and 4 with the Philharmonia Orchestra, while during the early 1950s, he also recorded extensively with the Paris Conservatory Orchestra and the Orchestra National de Radio France, the premier broadcasting orchestra in Paris, conducting both French and European repertoire by composers such as Fauré, Berlioz, and Bizet on the one hand, and Hayden, Schubert, and Schumann on the other.
Cluytens’s international career developed rapidly after he conducted the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra in 1955; the following year, he and Carl Schuricht led the orchestra on a tour of America. Also in 1955, he replaced an indisposed Eugene Jochum at the Bayreuth Festival, taking over the direction of Tannhäuser. As with the Vienna Philharmonic, he was to be invited to return several times to the Festival, to conduct Lohengrin and Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg. Finally in 1955, he made his first recording with the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 6 “Pastoral”, going on between 1957 and 1960 to record a complete cycle of Beethoven symphonies with the orchestra for EMI’s German branch Electrola.
A notable departure from the repertoire which Cluytens had hitherto focused upon in the recording studio came in 1958 when he accompanied the composer Dmitri Shostakovich in his two piano concertos and directed a powerful reading of that composer’s Symphony No. 11, subtitled “The Year 1905”, all with the French National Radio Orchestra. Also in 1958, he made his public conducting debut in London when he substituted for Otto Klemperer in a concert with the Philharmonia Orchestra. From 1959, Cluytens was contracted to appear regularly at the Vienna State Opera, and in 1960, he conducted Parsifal at La Scala, Milan; from 1960 until his death, he held the positions of chief conductor of the Beligian National Orchestra. Although ih declining health, he continued to be active in the recording studio, re-recording Boris Godunov in 1962 and Les Contes d’Hoffmann with a star-studded vocal cast in 1965, as well as exceptional accounts of the last two symphonies by Albert Roussel. André Cluytens died in Paris in 1967, aged only sixty-two.
The initial English/American critical response to Cluytens’s recordings was often muted. To the critics of the 1950s, he may not have possessed in the French repertoire the high-octane style of conducting such as Montreux and Munch, and so may have seemed a conductor for domestic consumption only. But in fact, herein lies the attraction of Cluytens as an interpreter of French music. Throughout all his performances there is on display exceptional musical good taste, reflected in elegant and stylish playing that draw attention to the music and not to the conductor: in both the operatic and symphonic French repertoire. Cluytens always secured performance of true Gallic character.
His ventures in the Austro-German and Russian repertoires were understandably fewer, but not wholly without interest. His two accounts of the Beethoven “Pastoral” Symphony have a tranquility and serenity, as well as a vigor entirely in keeping with the work but in fact seldom experienced. As an accompanist, Cluytens could be relied upon to offer punctilious as well as sympathetic support, as his many recordings in this capacity well demonstrate. His partnership with Emil Gilels in Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 3 is particularly exciting. He was a natural musician of great sensibility, whose immaculate sense to taste and style fortunately live on in his numerous recordings.
Taken from A-Z of conductors by David Patmore
Emil Gilels
OCtober 19, 1916 – October 14, 1985
Emil Gilels is considered by many to be one of the greatest pianists of all time. He led the way to the West for the great post-war generation of classical performers from the Soviet Union. Before his iconic peers — with pianist Sviatoslav Richter, violinist David Oistrakh and cellist Mstislav Rostropovich prime among them — Gilels was allowed to travel widely in the West, as a standard bearer for Soviet culture. He made a sensational American concert debut in 1955 with Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto No. 1, going on to record the work with the Chicago Symphony under Fritz Reiner. Five years later, he was the soloist for the first performance of a Soviet orchestra in the U.S., performing the Tchaikovsky concerto with the Moscow State Symphony at Carnegie Hall. Hailed in the West for his leonine athleticism at the keyboard — with “a Romantic bravura and imposing sonority that could penetrate any orchestra” — Gilels enjoyed critical acclaim across five decades; the Los Angeles Times noted “his flair both for thunderous virtuosity and songful tonal manipulation,” while The New York Times praised his “formidable, high-finish technique and beautiful control of nuance” later in his career.
Born in 1916, Gilels was raised as a musician from a young age in Odessa, Ukraine, giving his first public concert at age 12. He earned a name in the West in 1938 by winning Ysaÿe International Competition (later renamed the Queen Elisabeth Competition), in Brussels. In 1944, Gilels premiered Prokofiev’s Piano Sonata No. 8. That same decade, he formed a piano trio with Rostropovich and violinist Leonid Kogan, recording Haydn, Beethoven and Schumann. The pianist would win many state prizes in the U.S.S.R., and he chaired the jury of the inaugural International Tchaikovsky Competition that bravely awarded the gold medal to American pianist Van Cliburn in 1958.
Although less iconoclastic and charismatic than his contemporary Sviatoslav Richter — whom he admired — Gilels remained in high demand on both sides of the Iron Curtain. He recorded extensively for Russia’s Melodiya label and for RCA, Columbia, EMI and Deutsche Grammophon in the West. The pianist left famous versions of the two Brahms concertos with Eugen Jochum and the Berlin Philharmonic, as well as a complete Beethoven cycle with George Szell and the Cleveland Orchestra. Solo, Gilels ranged successfully from Scarlatti, Chopin, Schubert, Brahms and Liszt to Scriabin, Rachmaninoff, Debussy, Stravinsky and Bartók, engaging with living composers via Prokofiev and Shostakovich. Gilels turned to solo Mozart late in life, and he also recorded a hit LP of Grieg’s Lyric Pieces, raising the mainstream profile of the Nordic miniatures. At his death in 1985 at age 68, Gilels was working on a studio traversal of Beethoven’s complete piano sonatas, leaving five unrecorded. His version of the “Hammerklavier” Sonata won a Gramophone Award in 1984.